Manchester United Manager Odds: 23 Candidates to Succeed Michael Carrick

Michael Carrick was appointed as Manchester United’s interim manager in January, sparking hope among fans after a rocky period under Ruben Amorim. The team showed significant improvement, with Carrick securing more Premier League points than any other manager from his appointment until the end of the season. This success earned him a long-term deal following a surprising qualification for the Champions League.

Yet, the new season has not gone well. Carrick’s side has only one victory in six Premier League matches so far. They suffered a home loss to a 10-man Manchester City and squandered a 2-0 halftime lead against Brighton in the Carabao Cup, becoming the first United team in 50 years to lose at Old Trafford after leading by two goals at the break. A late Tottenham equalizer, despite Spurs playing with 10 men, and a 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid have only increased pressure on Carrick. Defender Lisandro Martinez publicly criticized the club for insufficient investment, adding to the tension.

Long-Shot Candidates with High Odds

• Lionel Scaloni (Argentina) – 80/1
• Ange Postecoglou (Al-Nassr) – 80/1
• David Moyes (Everton) – 80/1
• Roberto Mancini (Italy) – 66/1
• Ralf Rangnick (Austria) – 66/1
• Diego Simeone (Atletico Madrid) – 50/1
• Daniel Farke (Leeds United) – 50/1
• Brendan Rodgers (Al Qadsiah) – 50/1
• Sebastian Hoeness (VfB Stuttgart) – 50/1

David Moyes remains an unlikely return option despite being favored by Sir Alex Ferguson years ago. Ralf Rangnick, who once served as interim boss, is also considered unlikely to return given his past frustrations. Diego Simeone’s defensive approach might clash with United’s style, while Daniel Farke and Brendan Rodgers, though successful, would be risky choices due to their lack of experience managing clubs of United’s stature.

Mid-Range Options with Moderate Odds

• Luis Enrique (PSG) – 33/1
• Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (Unattached) – 25/1
• Mauricio Pochettino (USA) – 25/1
• Roberto Martinez (Unattached) – 22/1
• Darren Fletcher (Man Utd U18s) – 20/1
• Carlo Ancelotti (Brazil) – 20/1
• Gareth Southgate (Unattached) – 14/1

Luis Enrique continues to collect trophies with PSG but faces less pressure given his resources. Mauricio Pochettino, now with the USA national team, remains admired by the club. Darren Fletcher could serve as a temporary solution, but relying on former players for long-term success seems doubtful. Gareth Southgate, currently unattached, might bring fresh energy, though club management differs from international coaching.

Leading Contenders with Lower Odds

• Unai Emery (Aston Villa) – 14/1
• Thomas Tuchel (England) – 14/1
• Kieran McKenna (Unattached) – 10/1
• Julian Nagelsmann (Unattached) – 13/2
• Antonio Conte (Napoli) – 5/1
• Fabian Hurzeler (Brighton & Hove Albion) – 5/1
• Eddie Howe (Unattached) – 2/1

Unai Emery has rebuilt his reputation with Aston Villa after a tough spell at Arsenal. Thomas Tuchel, England’s manager, is another option but probably won’t leave before Euro 2028. Kieran McKenna, who once worked under Jose Mourinho and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer at United, might get a chance despite being unattached. Julian Nagelsmann, free after Germany’s disappointing World Cup campaign, remains a hot prospect. Antonio Conte’s track record for quick impact makes him attractive. Fabian Hurzeler, a young and promising coach at Brighton, appears ready for bigger challenges. Eddie Howe stands out as the clear favorite, having recently resigned from Newcastle and widely expected to return swiftly to management.

All odds are provided by SkyBet and were accurate as of October 14, 2026.